Not bad but a little weird, some hints of pumpkin, lots of maltiness, a little funk in there as well. Good, not great.

Pretty cool stout, a little harsh in the nose but some nice maltiness up front followed by some really nice smokiness that lingers.

Really delicious! Surprisingly low oxidation and still a lovely mellow sweetness, really hides its ABV.

The cotton candy is subdued, but this is still tasting great, especially as it warms up a bit.

Amazing; calling it a barley wine seems almost cheating, it's super thick, awesome marshmallow sweetness coupled with a roastiness in the finish. This is great.

Lots of malt, bread character, kind of a mediocre barleywine on second take.

Good carbonation, dull smokiness in the nose, mild sweetness, well balanced. A good barley wine, no syrup to be found.

Super cheese in an amazing way, less fruit than the fresher (2016) bottle but a little more character to the funk. Delicious.

That perfect Cantillon funk, along with a surprising amount of fruit presence (not much must) coupled with the traditional sour backend. Awesome, was a great line beer waiting for Beatification.

Delicious, love the roast malt flavors that form the core of this beer, would never know it's 10%.

Still a surprising amount of coffee, and tasting great, thick, not too hot, and that great BCBS stout character. Still digging it.

Tasting great, though as expected a bit muted on the coffee compared to drinking it fresh.

Much sweeter than remembered, though not in a bad way, coffee definitely subdued but still present in the nose and on the backend, has some of that BCBW marshmellow I remember too. Tasting great.

Still great, lots of coffee on the nose and on the palate, and so drinkable for the ABV, hardly any heat. A great blend.

Sooo much coffee presence, delicious and up front, much better than the 2012 bottle opened a while back. Superb and not grounds-like, just a great blend, should drink another soon.

So great fresh.

Delicious! Fun new format, too. Sweeter than I remember, but great hop character (and aroma!) too.

A little more watery than I remember, but great hop nose and character. Lagunitas hop water.

Delicious! Fun new format, too. Sweeter than I remember, but great hop character (and aroma!) too.

A little more watery than I remember, but great hop nose and character. Lagunitas hop water.

Great; easier drinking than Black Tuesday, with great chocolate overtones (though not too on the nose) with some roasted character. Another huge ABV winner from The Bruery.

Delicious! Like an apple specific version of Serendipity.

A biscuit like nose, pretty mild on the palate, barleywine up front with more bread as it progresses. Not great.

Tons of yeast, swirling clouds of it, prevalent in the nose as well, no booze but some nice sweetness on the palate, not bad but not stellar.

Great bitterness and roast, with a bit of sweet up front, has held up really well. I think I hit it about right in terms of when to enjoy this last bottle.

Started off a bit bland, but really came along as it warmed up, great bitterness coupled with nicely balanced stout character.

What an amazing imperial stout. Great balance, perfect carbonation, and a complex finish with oak, coffee, and vanilla. Love it.