Really weird and not good nose, but the taste is actually pretty good, with the agave up front and some mild tequila and barrel on the finish.

Delicious as always, still a lot of fruit, perfectly carbed, and definitely a bit more pucker than when fresh.

Pretty good! I think I'm still more a fan of regular and coffee BCBS, but the cherry here is well done, and it got better as it warmed, too.

Alas, this one apparently went bad, a bit of a rancid aftertaste on the finish. Must have ben infected?

Really delicious, smooth, light (in a good way) on the vanilla, and a bit of heat on the finish. Love it.

Tasty, age brings out some of the raisin characteristics, overall mellow and drinkable.

Still delicious, has held up really well, glad to have one more of these to drink, and should probably bring it up soon-ish.

Still a good roast on the nose, a teensy bit of bite, and great ashen chocolate and sweet malt characteristics. This thing is pretty nice after a year.

Quite tasty!

Brownie in the nose, fun! Sweet and a little smoke, slight bitter on the finish. Tasty.

Still amazing! Mellow, some spice, lovely vanilla.

Really does capture a peach cobbler; delicious beer, got better as it warmed up too.

Not bad, definitely mellowed out since last I had it, nothing too special at this point but a solid quad.

Pretty good, despite being entirely flat. Lots of fruit and barrel in the nose, and backed up with some serious tartness on the palate.

Great as always, has held up well, unlike the larger format.

Great as always, white wine and fruit forward nose, an acidic but balanced beer on the palate, could drink it all (sunny) day.

Not very good, the smoke turned more to a slight tartness, and the barrel aging hasn't held up.

Smoky! Big rye in the nose, less in the taste, some mild porter/stout notes, and otherwise smokiness. Oh the smokiness. Heavy on the finish, like the Lagavulin of beers.

Drank the Batch 8 bottle, not bad though a little flat, and wonder if this one might even be past its prime. Still, a great beer.

Awesome, great wine notes, tasting so great. Not sure how much aging will do for these as they're so good from the get go.

Great sour blonde, has that amazing Russian River balance

Still delicious, a little less fruit than before but can't help but love this beer.

Still great, love this beer. Color is awesome, still lots of fruit in the nose and on the palette, amazing. Wish this was a regular for them.

Still lots of mint! Hope they do this beer again, super delicious.

Still lots of mint, dark chocolate, very little booziness. Love it.

Tasting great, very much like a peppermint patty with lots of chocolate and a subtle amount of mint. Great beer, glad I grabbed extras.

The mint is possibly fading a tad, but still an amazingly delicious beer. So well done.

This beer is amazing. The mint works so well. Wish I had more in the cellar than just two!

This was delicious! Was scared mint would overwhelm, but was extremely subtle and a perfect compliment. Should age well, must resist temptation to drink them all now.