Very good, seems dryer than fresh. Some chunks at bottom.

Doing very well. Good coffee notes, good finish.

Still big on coffee. Drier than I recall. Excellent.

Coffee prominent. Barrel wood but not not much bourbon. Great overall.

Lovely, still good cherry flavors. Tempered sourness

Loved by the ladies and men. Fruit still showing, and sourness very low.

Very good. Dove camp.

Cherry still coming through and quite enjoyable. A bit more tart since release.

Surprisingly perfect like last time. Shocked at how this ale is aging with great body, slightly diminished nose. Taste is a boozy caramel with chocolate and coffee notes.

Aging incredibly well. Continues to be my favorite barleywine.

Oxidized badly but drinkable. Enjoyed.

Seems to be making a comeback. Finish is off but not terribly. Good roasty and cocoa notes. Enjoyable.

Super happy with this bottle. Roasty malt, great color, no flaws. Even the finish is clean. Great mouthfell. Might be drier than originally.

Holding up but the end is coming

Surprisingly good!

Now sure these have much longer to go. Very drinkable but getting some aftertaste issues.

Still drinking like a champ. Good carbonation, crisp, delicious.

Vintage 2012 330mL bottle poured 12/4/17 to tulip, black, viscous, big brown head, no lacing. Nose a bit flat, some wood. Taste is not flat. Bourbon, coffee, chocolate, vanilla meld on a big body roasty malt base. Some booziness and a slightly bitter finish.

Similar to last time. Now showing some off flavors. Still amazing.

Really good. Robust smoked malt, anise flavors. Great body.

Black pour to snifter, big beige head, good retention, some lacing. Nose of roasted malt and chocolate. Taste on this 2012 bottle is showing some signs of oxidation but overall has held up well. Roasty malt notes are a bit muted, and the finish light chocolate. Above average body and average carbonation.

No gusher this time. Great balance of tart and funk. Mild hop presence.

Simply amazing. Gusher. Everything else is perfect. Great flavors with small oxidation.

Fantastic! Hint of mushroom and light sourness. Carbonation dropped off but otherwise excellent.

Enjoyed at HCBS #27. Drinking very well!

Poolside share with my babe, Patrick, Sue, Janine, and Sam. Accolades from all. Amazing for the age and great flavors.

Tastes like JK. No trace of degradation.

Still bright hops, evergreen. Some oxidation affecting the malt but very enjoyable.

Too oxidized, cola all the way