Delicious and tastes like apples (what more can you ask for?) Cami has most of it.

Coffe mostly fallen out, but still a delicious stout.

A little more coffee sharpness in this one, probably a fresher batch, still great, went well with some semisweet chocolate chips for dessert.

Still lots of mint! Hope they do this beer again, super delicious.

Still lots of mint, dark chocolate, very little booziness. Love it.

Tasting great, very much like a peppermint patty with lots of chocolate and a subtle amount of mint. Great beer, glad I grabbed extras.

The mint is possibly fading a tad, but still an amazingly delicious beer. So well done.

This beer is amazing. The mint works so well. Wish I had more in the cellar than just two!

This was delicious! Was scared mint would overwhelm, but was extremely subtle and a perfect compliment. Should age well, must resist temptation to drink them all now.

Drank this one too late in a night of drinking, but remember it being good.

A little more fruit than the 2014 opened at the same time, but a little less developed profile. Tasty but not the winner.

Great fruit character, bright color, super tart, some citrus. Great.

Really hot, lots of booze, not too much smoke, and ending very sweet. Not the best.

Just a hint of fruit, and lots of tart. Quite good.

Definitely less fruit than the fresh bottling, but still delicious. Digging it.

Still a lot of oak, a great, drinkable malt profile, and an all around quaffable Belgian style ale, especially given the ABV.

Lots of oak in the nose and up front on the palate, no alcohol heat, some grains, delicious.

Still a surprising amount of coffee, and tasting great, thick, not too hot, and that great BCBS stout character. Still digging it.

Tasting great, though as expected a bit muted on the coffee compared to drinking it fresh.

Much sweeter than remembered, though not in a bad way, coffee definitely subdued but still present in the nose and on the backend, has some of that BCBW marshmellow I remember too. Tasting great.

Still great, lots of coffee on the nose and on the palate, and so drinkable for the ABV, hardly any heat. A great blend.

Sooo much coffee presence, delicious and up front, much better than the 2012 bottle opened a while back. Superb and not grounds-like, just a great blend, should drink another soon.

Really nice and mild, hibiscus expressed as a mellow backing to a less tart version of their typical golden sour. Pleasant.

Hibiscus faded but still there, especially in the nose, and just a really solid sour profile, not too funky or brett forward, just right in both areas. Delicious.

More body than the 2015 with a little less fruit, but definitely the better of the two.

Not much fruit left but a very pleasantly tart and mellow framboise, with hints of sweetness coming through.

Delicious as always, not too much raspberry left but still lots of citrus, and that perfect Russian River sour profile.

Delicious, amazing color, great nose, lots of citrus and still a good bit of fruit there. Amazing beer.

Still tasting amazing, plenty of fruit, best color of the batches tonight, if anything tasting a little more balanced now than it did fresh.

Delicious, some lemon character, mild raspberry, great tang, a good start.

Possibly unfair as tastes just after the coffee BCBS, but tasted a bit thin with a bit of anise, and generally good but not standout.

Tasty, malty, not too sour, a solid dark wild ale. Like a Supplication but a bit maltier.

Lots of pluot, but I didn't taste much as it didn't mesh with fresh brushed teeth. However, the wife adored it.