3 y.o. 4.1 really taste, but really large dark chunks

5 yo 4.1 good but a little too bitter still

4 yo 4.2 good not great

3 yo 4.2 very smooth and tasty

2.5 y.o. 4.15 good but not great

2 years 4.0 a little bitterness still

4.25- very good but still a little too bitter

Excellent at 1 year, 4.35

4.25 Excellent smooth and flavorful at one year

4

1.5 years 4.1 very smooth

4.0

Mini vert 18 months vs. 12 months. Both around 4.0. 12 month was better as the 18 month had a little smokey flavor. Both very smooth, no alcohol bite and only very slight bitterness. But not a lot of complexity or other good flavors either - not a lot of chocolate or brunt sugar sweetness.

4.2 very good with a unique flavor

4.1 good, nice adjunct orange flavor and smooth, but thin and lacking richness.

6 mo. 4.2

fresh 4.0 not a lot of unique flavor - no coconut and no particularly great sweet flavors of a BA IS.

2018 2 yo 4.25 very good, slight bitterness

2017 3 yo 4.2 good but a little bit bitter still

2016 - 4 yo 4.2 not as sweet as some others - still slightly bitter

1 y.o. 2016 but a newly purchased bottle on a rerelease from Sulry. 4.25 very good but a little too bitter yet. Maybe not as "aged" as the one I had in the basement for a year?

1 y.o. 2016 4.45 Excellent - maybe the best non BA IS I've had, super sweet burnt sugar roasted flavors

bb 2025 so maybe 2 y.o. (or more) 3.9 smooth but not a lot of flavor

2.75 yo 4.3 super smooth and tasty

2 yo 4.3 smooth strong barrel

20 mo. 4.25 very good, smooth and tasty

4.35 really good flavor with some burnt sugar sweetness

15 mo. excellent 4.3 even better as it warmed more - best with burnt sugar flavors at the end

1 year 4.3 barrel aroma, taste some roasted marshmallow as it warms, still a little hot and could smooth out more

1 yr. (almost) 4.25 nice barrel still, smooth, flavorful brunt sugar/roast

9 mo. 4.4 very good, super smooth 2017-10-08 7 months or so. 4.5 excellent. hot but not too much so - more so flavorful. sweet brunt sugar, roasted marshmallow. 2017-04-09 4.5 excellent 2017-04-02 excellent 2017-03-12 4.5 very good - extremely smooth, no alcohol bite or bitterness

2 y.o. 3.9 Good, slightly unique taste, but nothing especially good.

2017 10 mo. 4.3 great, but not quite as sticky sweet as older bottles

2016 Vintage 2017-11-25 Actual drink date 20 month 4.5 excellent super sweet

4.9 2017 Vintage (I think) if so 7 months old. So sweet and smooth. I can't think of any way this could be better. After having others, I now wonder if this was a 2016 that was 19 months old?

3.8 smooth but not a lot of flavor, very little to no coconut

14 month 4.2 - now very good

1 y.o. real good now, 4.0+ smooth and tasty

almost 11 months old - 4.2 getting very good.

4.1 better yet at 10 month

9 months - pretty good now 4+

4.0 pretty good now

4.0 seems better - less barrel hot

Better yet. Good strong barrel.

Like it a bit better - maybe expectations were too high

ok - strong barrel but not the quad sweetness i expected

1.5 years 4.1 Interesting with multiple flavors.

3.9 good smooth but not that flavorful

3.9 good

2 mo. 4.0 smooth but not lots of flavor

fresh - 4.0 very good but a little bitterness - maybe needs a little time?