2 years <4.0 smokey/sour flavor (not good for me)

Mini vert 18 months vs. 12 months. Both around 4.0. 12 month was better as the 18 month had a little smokey flavor. Both very smooth, no alcohol bite and only very slight bitterness. But not a lot of complexity or other good flavors either - not a lot of chocolate or brunt sugar sweetness.

Good. A little smoky flavor???

4.25 very good at a year. smooth not bitter nice roast flavors

fresh/ 3 months old 4.25 like UJS with peanuts (prefer UJS)

4.3 complex very good, more flavorful as it warms

4.25 very good, maybe could be more integrated??? Maybe age for a while?

4.5 excellent - smooth interesting complex taste

18 months old 4.0 very good but lot of floaty sediment

1.5 years - 4.2

4.0 very good. smooth sweet BW flavors.

3.5 good but not great

fresh - good but a bit too barrel hot 6 mo old - very good, a bit a aged old ale sherry type sweetness with still strong barrel presence 1 year - very good, smooth, especially in a vert with fresh

2015 3 y.o. 4.5 Excellent - super sweet and smooth.

2 year 4 months old. 4.4 very good -sweet and smooth

4.1 losing sweetness

4.25 losing sweetness?

4.5 Excellent at 20 months

excellent at 1.5 years

4.5ish super sweet and delicious at one year very much like a sherry morphed old ale

4.47 Super sweet and tasty - similar to samiclaus, JW Lees, Fullers.

3.9 good - different

4. 0 6 months - real good, still plenty of coffee

4.2

4.0 A - dark almost black S - coffee with some sweetness T - very strong smoked flavor (not my preference) smooth but lighter than expected - strong coffee but little to no chocolate (as advertised) but good M - fairly thin (but maybe I'm thinking about stouts with the coffee/chocolate aspect) O - very good

3.9 good - different

4. 0 6 months - real good, still plenty of coffee

4.2

4.0 A - dark almost black S - coffee with some sweetness T - very strong smoked flavor (not my preference) smooth but lighter than expected - strong coffee but little to no chocolate (as advertised) but good M - fairly thin (but maybe I'm thinking about stouts with the coffee/chocolate aspect) O - very good

2018 2 yo 4.25 very good, slight bitterness

2017 3 yo 4.2 good but a little bit bitter still

2016 - 4 yo 4.2 not as sweet as some others - still slightly bitter

1 y.o. 2016 but a newly purchased bottle on a rerelease from Sulry. 4.25 very good but a little too bitter yet. Maybe not as "aged" as the one I had in the basement for a year?

1 y.o. 2016 4.45 Excellent - maybe the best non BA IS I've had, super sweet burnt sugar roasted flavors

2.5 yo 4.3 very good, smooth and tasty flavor from the coconut.

4.4 love it - sweet, smooth, and flavorful

4.35 excellent smooth and flavorful

6 mo. 4.3 tasty but not super strong on the coconut or sweetness, very smooth with no bitterness

Fresh 4.35 excellent - not that coconuty but smooth, sweet and tasty

almost 4 years old 4.25, very good roasted malts, coffee flavor and dark slightly bitter chocolate

10 months 4.25 very good - smooth, light coffee no heat, great aroma

4.35 very good at 4 months - coffee still very good but not too strong. smooth and tasty.

2 y.o. 4.0 good very roasted malt but not great

very good with a year on it - bitterness is gone

5 mo. 4.1 very good, subtle adjuncts but tasty

4.2 very good, smooth not bitter at all, unique flavor

3.9 good smooth but not that flavorful

3.9 good

2 mo. 4.0 smooth but not lots of flavor

fresh - 4.0 very good but a little bitterness - maybe needs a little time?

1 y.o. 4.4 excellent sticky sweet

6 months 4.5 excellent, super smooth and flavorful with quad flavors and nice barrel accents

fresh 4.5 excellent - sweet and flavorful