20 months 4.6 Excellent. Tasted vs. a fresh 2017, less spicy, and way more vanilla and chocolate. Much better than the fresh bottle.

4.35 still just as good

Still very good 4.25

losing some flavor at 6 months, I think.

Really really good, sweet smooth and flavorful. At least 4.5

great!

about 4 months. vanilla aroma very prominent and nice. coffee is down a lot in nose and taste. 4.5

still just as good - a bit more cinnamon in the taste

4.41/5 rDev -0.7% look: 4.25 | smell: 4.5 | taste: 4.5 | feel: 4.25 | overall: 4.25 L - nice dark black with a big tan head S - Coffee, chocolate,vanilla and barrel T - Layered with the same as the aroma with cinnamon coming in lightly late in the taste through the finish M - nice, not too heavy but somewhat sticky O - very good, a great complex BA stout and a value for the price

10 mo. old - not as good maybe 4.0

4.3 Very good - butter/butterscotch flavor

good but not great at 10 months. definitely dropped off. better fresher.

Excellent - still as good. Still plenty of coffee.

4.5 excellent very smooth and flavorful try again at 6 months

1 yr old bottle 4.35 still delicious, coffee still present, very smooth and sweet, no bitterness

Very Good as always.

4.25 very good - strong coffee, smooth with no bitterness

Delicious big chocolate and coffee - very smooth, no bitterness. Last fresh one review on BA - 4.51

3.9 good but not worth chasing

< 4 ok 7 months old still a little harsh

4.1 now 4 months old. Getting better - smoother

4 very good. Not as good as CW? A little too hot?

3.9 good but not worth chasing

< 4 ok 7 months old still a little harsh

4.1 now 4 months old. Getting better - smoother

4 very good. Not as good as CW? A little too hot?

3.751 year old. Great chocolate aroma. Taste - Coffee apparent but not real strong. Good, but maple syrup was too much.

4+ 2017 fresh

4+ 2017 fresh

4ish not sour

10 months 3.5 sour taste has developed

very good

4+ very good

4.0 losing barrel for sure

4 9 months - might be losing some of the barrel flavor.

4.25 at 7 months

4/4.25 still very good

Excellent

Still very good - but, might be losing some flavor???

still very good

4.25 Great scotch ale

8 y.o. 4 - surprisingly it's good again, sweet tasty

3 Not good. Smell is still sweet, but nothing in the flavor.

Still good, but not as sweet as I remembered. 4ish

4.45/5 rDev +6.7% look: 3.5 | smell: 4.75 | taste: 4.5 | feel: 4 | overall: 4.5 2009 vintage A - Apple cider, cloudy S - Dark fruit, stone fruit, very nice strong aromas T - Same dark and stone fruit with a nice boozy flavor, with no alcohol burn M - nice fairly chewy O - very good, tasty and very smooth

4+ 2017 fresh

4+ 2017 fresh

4ish not sour

10 months 3.5 sour taste has developed

very good

4+ very good

4.0 losing barrel for sure

4 9 months - might be losing some of the barrel flavor.

4.25 at 7 months

4/4.25 still very good

Excellent

Still very good - but, might be losing some flavor???

still very good

4.25 Great scotch ale

10 mo. old - not as good maybe 4.0

4.3 Very good - butter/butterscotch flavor

5 yo 4.1 good but a little too bitter still

4 yo 4.2 good not great

3 yo 4.2 very smooth and tasty

2.5 y.o. 4.15 good but not great

2 years 4.0 a little bitterness still

4.25- very good but still a little too bitter

Excellent at 1 year, 4.35

4.25 Excellent smooth and flavorful at one year

5 yo 4.1 good but a little too bitter still

4 yo 4.2 good not great

3 yo 4.2 very smooth and tasty

2.5 y.o. 4.15 good but not great

2 years 4.0 a little bitterness still

4.25- very good but still a little too bitter

Excellent at 1 year, 4.35

4.25 Excellent smooth and flavorful at one year

4.15 Very good at 15 months. chocolate, roasted malts, smooth not bitter.

very good

3 yo 4.0 smooth pretty tasty but not very sweet

3 y. o. 4.15

Liked it a lot at 1 year. Very flavorful. 4.25?