3.9 good but a bit light

4+ 2017 fresh

4+ 2017 fresh

4ish not sour

10 months 3.5 sour taste has developed

very good

4+ very good

4.0 losing barrel for sure

4 9 months - might be losing some of the barrel flavor.

4.25 at 7 months

4/4.25 still very good

Excellent

Still very good - but, might be losing some flavor???

still very good

4.25 Great scotch ale

4+ very good - richer than fresh

liking it even a bit better at 14 mo. maybe close to 4

3.75 at 11 months, good but not that sweet

3.9 good but not worth chasing

< 4 ok 7 months old still a little harsh

4.1 now 4 months old. Getting better - smoother

4 very good. Not as good as CW? A little too hot?

4.25+ vanilla bourbon barrel with a little heat, subtle coffee and sweet burnt sugar

good - i think better fresh

4.25 very good, smooth marshmallow sweet.

10 months. 4.375 - coffee pretty much gone. still sweet and tasty, w/ burnt sugar, toasty roasted marshmallow. Drink fresher. Definitely need to have this warmer - 45-55 is too low at the low end. 55 is best.

2 months 4.55/5 rDev 0% look: 4.25 | smell: 4.75 | taste: 4.5 | feel: 4.5 | overall: 4.5 A - Dark brown smallish tan head S - Super - sweet burnt sugar smell T - Awesome complex sweetness, burnt sugar, vanilla, coffee M - nice and sticky O - Excellent, so smooth sweet and tasty

4+ 2017 fresh

4+ 2017 fresh

4ish not sour

10 months 3.5 sour taste has developed

very good

4+ very good

4.0 losing barrel for sure

4 9 months - might be losing some of the barrel flavor.

4.25 at 7 months

4/4.25 still very good

Excellent

Still very good - but, might be losing some flavor???

still very good

4.25 Great scotch ale

2 y.o. 4.0 good very roasted malt but not great

very good with a year on it - bitterness is gone

4.15 Very good at 15 months. chocolate, roasted malts, smooth not bitter.

very good

5 yo 4.1 good but a little too bitter still

4 yo 4.2 good not great

3 yo 4.2 very smooth and tasty

2.5 y.o. 4.15 good but not great

2 years 4.0 a little bitterness still

4.25- very good but still a little too bitter

Excellent at 1 year, 4.35

4.25 Excellent smooth and flavorful at one year

3.75 light for an IS.

20 months 4.6 Excellent. Tasted vs. a fresh 2017, less spicy, and way more vanilla and chocolate. Much better than the fresh bottle.

4.35 still just as good

Still very good 4.25

losing some flavor at 6 months, I think.

Really really good, sweet smooth and flavorful. At least 4.5

great!

about 4 months. vanilla aroma very prominent and nice. coffee is down a lot in nose and taste. 4.5

still just as good - a bit more cinnamon in the taste

4.41/5 rDev -0.7% look: 4.25 | smell: 4.5 | taste: 4.5 | feel: 4.25 | overall: 4.25 L - nice dark black with a big tan head S - Coffee, chocolate,vanilla and barrel T - Layered with the same as the aroma with cinnamon coming in lightly late in the taste through the finish M - nice, not too heavy but somewhat sticky O - very good, a great complex BA stout and a value for the price

Way down from fresh 4/4.25

Definitely losing taste - less flavorful and more bitterness coming through.

I think it is dropping off. Some bitterness which is surprising - that should dissipate. Maybe the lessening coffee is allowing that to come through.

still great

Still strong coffee flavor

very good, very smooth, no bitterness at all

excellent coffee and chocolate, but a slight bitterness at the finish - is there a sweet spot where this dies off before you lose the coffee too much?

4.58/5 rDev +0.4% | Avg: 4.56 look: 4.75 | smell: 4.75 | taste: 4.5 | feel: 4.5 | overall: 4.5 Fresh as possible - 4/1 release, purchase and consumption A - Super black with a tremendous tan/brown head S - Very strong and pleasing coffee and chocolate T - Delicious with coffee flavor dominance, very slight bitterness at the finish F - Thick and oily O - Fantastic coffee stout - results meet the hype. Lucky enough to have landed 11 more that I'll consume over time (up to one year unless it starts lose too much coffee).

14 month 4.2 - now very good

1 y.o. real good now, 4.0+ smooth and tasty

almost 11 months old - 4.2 getting very good.

4.1 better yet at 10 month

9 months - pretty good now 4+

4.0 pretty good now

4.0 seems better - less barrel hot

Better yet. Good strong barrel.

Like it a bit better - maybe expectations were too high

ok - strong barrel but not the quad sweetness i expected

3.9 good but not worth chasing

< 4 ok 7 months old still a little harsh

4.1 now 4 months old. Getting better - smoother

4 very good. Not as good as CW? A little too hot?

3.9 good but a bit light