| I Think I Just Scored! | Local Craft Beer | Imperial IPA | 10.0% |
| I Think I Saw | The Eighth State Brewing Company | American Imperial Stout | |
| I Think She Hung The Moon | Naughty Brewing Co. | | 8.6% |
| I Think We Should Go Home | Burial Beer Co. | Imperial IPA | 8.2% |
| I Think We're Gonna Be Alright | Burial Beer Co. | New England IPA | 8.5% |
| I Used to be an Adventurer Like You | Sureshot Brewing Co. | American Pale Ale | 5.0% |
| I Voted | 903 Brewers | Cream Ale | 5.0% |
| I wanna be your dog | BrewDog Ltd | American Imperial Stout | 12.0% |
| I Wanna Be Your Dog | Omnipollo | American Imperial Stout | 12.0% |
| I Want Everything | Magnify Brewing | | |
| I Want It Now! | Funky Buddha Lounge and Brewery | | |
| I Want It Owl, I Want It Now! | Brouwerij het Uiltje | Eisbock | 15.5% |
| I Want My HTV | Odd Side Ales | Imperial IPA | 9.0% |
| I Want My HTV | Odd Side Ales | Imperial IPA | 9.0% |
| I Want Smore | Tioga-Sequoia Brewing Company | American Stout | 7.2% |