| I Can Brew For Miles and Miles | Mikerphone | Milkshake IPA | 7.5% |
| I Can See My Helles From Here | Trophy Brewing Company | Helles | 5.5% |
| I Can't Feel My Face | Local Craft Beer | Imperial IPA | 10.0% |
| I Can't Wait To Still Be Pouring This Barleywine In June | Evil Twin | American Barleywine | 12.0% |
| I Can’t Help But Feel A Specific Anger Of Waiting In Line To Swipe At The SubwY Turnstile Behind Someone Hwo Does Not Know How To Swipe | Evil Twin | Imperial IPA | 8.5% |
| I Cavalieri Birra Speciale Rossa | Mastri Birrai Umbri | American Amber / Red Ale | 5.6% |
| I Choo Choo Choose You | Barreled Souls | | |
| I Contain Multitudes | Resident Culture Brewing Company | | |
| I Did It All For the Wookie | Divine Barrel Brewing | American IPA | 7.2% |
| I DO... IPA | Bearded Rabbit Brewery | American IPA | 6.5% |
| I Don’t Like Mondays | Fat Orange Cat | | |
| I Feel The Universe | Finback Brewery | Gose | 5.0% |
| I Get Those Gose Bumps Everytime | Brouwerij Frontaal | Fruit and Field Beer | 8.5% |
| I got 2 Marshmallows and a peanut butter | Prairie Artisan Ales | American Imperial Stout | 14.0% |
| I Got 5 On It | Amor Artis Brewing | | |