| I Got 5 On It | Fonta Flora | American IPA | 7.0% |
| I Got Guava Worms | AF Brew | | |
| I Hardcore You | Mikkeller | Imperial IPA | 9.5% |
| I Hate My Boss | Spiteful Brewing Company | American Stout | 6.5% |
| I Have No Idea Where This Will Lead Us, But I Have A Definite Feeling It Will Be An IPA Both Wonderful and Strange | Evil Twin | Imperial IPA | 10.5% |
| I Have Promises to Keep | Tree House Brewing Company | New England IPA | 7.9% |
| I Have Spoken | Bolero Snort | | |
| I Heart Pomegranate & Pineapple | Garage Project | Fruit and Field Beer | 6.1% |
| I Know for a Fact You Don't Party | Burial Beer Co. | American Imperial Stout | 10.0% |
| I Know The Sound Guy | Angry Chair Brewing | American Imperial Stout | |
| I Know What I Am | Brouwerij Frontaal | American IPA | 5.5% |
| I Let My Tape Rock | J. Wakefield Brewing | American Imperial Stout | 17.0% |
| I Like It Like That | Prairie Artisan Ales | American Imperial Stout | 14.0% |
| I Like My Sugar with Coffee and Cream | Other Half Brewing Co. | | 15.0% |
| I Like To Moob It Moob It | Northern Monk Brew Co | Imperial IPA | 8.8% |