3.5 sour - either light stuck or infected

4.2 very good but no real coconut presence - a bit expensive for what it is

2 mo old 4.25 really good, smooth and tasty

4.2 Solid BA coffee IS

2017 10 mo. 4.3 great, but not quite as sticky sweet as older bottles

2016 Vintage 2017-11-25 Actual drink date 20 month 4.5 excellent super sweet

4.9 2017 Vintage (I think) if so 7 months old. So sweet and smooth. I can't think of any way this could be better. After having others, I now wonder if this was a 2016 that was 19 months old?

2 y.o. 2016 a little sharpe but tasty, not hot, and kicking

1 y.o. 4.2 getting even better, a bit hot but very flavorful burnt sugar taste.

4 very good - interesting, fun to drink, not too hot fresh as expected. had to sip slowly, probably would be better with some time.

4 mo. old 4.15 starting to get that soury taste the aged ones had.

4.3 smooth not bitter and some brunt sugar sweetness as it warms

4.25 very good - smooth and tasty

Fresh 4.3 very good - super smooth for a BA IS

13 months 4.0 2016 very good, smooth but a bit soury and not as sweet and rich and flavorful as the fresh 2017's I've had recently. Could be a difference from years, but maybe just better fresh.

2016 3 yo 4.35 really good, tasty and flavorful but maybe could be even less bitter/hoppy although only slightly so

2015 3 y.o. 4.3 Excellent super smooth, no bitterness. Tasty roasted malt flavors.

2017-10-22 1 y.o. 2016 but a newly purchased bottle on a rerelease from Surly. 4.25 very good but a little too bitter yet. Maybe not as "aged" as the one I had in the basement for a year? 2017-09-13 1 y.o. 2016 4.45 Excellent - maybe the best non BA IS I've had, super sweet burnt sugar roasted flavors

2015 2 y.o. 4.25 super smooth, tasty. From back room stash Royal Liquor in Leucadia.

1 y.o. appx (2016 12/17) 4.3 heat down, smooth, tasty, sweet but not quite as sweet as I would like yet

3.75 fresh - too hot. Great flavor base, but this needs aome aging/mellowing for me.

4+ good but nothing special

4.1 solid smooth

fresh 4.0 smooth but not a ton of flavor

mini vert 1 year vs. fresh - liked the fresh slightly better as it had more (barrel) flavor but the one year was super smooth.

11 mo. 4.2 very good

4.2 7 mo. old very good, chocolatey

4.0 good not great - not very complex. just an off night or falling off?

4.5 now seems way better - very chocolatey, vanilla, smooth

4.2 very good. something in the finish/aftertaste could be better.

Good not spectacular, maybe 4.1

Fresh 4.85 coconut, chocolate, good subtle barrel, smooth no heat at all. Unbelievable.

14 mo. 4.0 real good, but not as sweet as I like.

1 y.o. 4+ smooth, good but slight sour Belgian IS flavor

1 y.o. 4.0 smooth, good, but slight sour and smokey flavor

4+

4.3 Age unknown, but would guess at least a couple of years from all the sediment. Really tasty, strong nicely present but smooth barrel along with scotch ale butterscotch flavors.

4+ good but nothing special

4.1 solid smooth

fresh 4.0 smooth but not a ton of flavor

mini vert 1 year vs. fresh - liked the fresh slightly better as it had more (barrel) flavor but the one year was super smooth.

11 mo. 4.2 very good

4.2 7 mo. old very good, chocolatey

4.0 good not great - not very complex. just an off night or falling off?

4.5 now seems way better - very chocolatey, vanilla, smooth

4.2 very good. something in the finish/aftertaste could be better.

Good not spectacular, maybe 4.1

4.15 smooth, tasty spices, thin

14 month 4.2 - now very good

1 y.o. real good now, 4.0+ smooth and tasty

almost 11 months old - 4.2 getting very good.

4.1 better yet at 10 month

9 months - pretty good now 4+

4.0 pretty good now

4.0 seems better - less barrel hot

Better yet. Good strong barrel.

Like it a bit better - maybe expectations were too high

ok - strong barrel but not the quad sweetness i expected