5 yo 4.1 good but a little too bitter still

4 yo 4.2 good not great

3 yo 4.2 very smooth and tasty

2.5 y.o. 4.15 good but not great

2 years 4.0 a little bitterness still

4.25- very good but still a little too bitter

Excellent at 1 year, 4.35

4.25 Excellent smooth and flavorful at one year

2016 4.5 yo 4.35 very good

4.35

2016 almost 2 yo 4.4 sweet and smooth

4.0 a little soury - rum barrel aged

6 yo 4.3 very good.

2017 4 yo 4.35 excellent

4.3 not as sweet

2016 4 yo 4.4 excellent

2017 3 yo 4.3 very good - a little less sweet toffee/caramel than I remember and a little (good) smokey-ish? flavor.

2017 2 yo 4.25 very good, but not as good as I thought it would be - maybe too cold

2017 1.75 yo 4.4 excellent

2017 18 mo. 4.35 very good, better as it warms more

2017 18 mo. 4.3 very good sweet and flavorful

2017 1 yo 4.3 very good, super smooth and sweet

2017 6 mo. old very good 4.35 even some burnt sugar as it really warmed. Drink warmer.

2017 fresh 4.25 not as sweet and smooth as the 2016 1 y.o. was. Lack of smoothness not bitterness, but acetone (?) alcohol flavor

2016 1 y.o. 4.75 Excellent smooth sweet perfection of an EBW 2016

4.75 excellent strong barrel aroma but smooth taste, nicely sweet with perfect barrel accent

3.0 tasty but horrible (yeast) chunks

2016 2 y.o. 4.3 very good - not sure it's better than the 2017 I had recently

2017 1 y.o. 4.35 very good

2017 1 yo 4.2

2017 10 months old 4.35 excellent

Fresh 2017 4.35 Really good - but not as good as the 1 y.o. 2016 from the prior week

1 y.o. 4.25 very good, smooth toasty roasted sweet nut influenced flavor

4.1 Pecan/roasted nut flavor was nice, slight roasted sugar flavor. Could be sweeter.

1 yo 4.2

9+ mo. 4.2 very good, smooth and tasty, but had a t a Brewer game

4.0 Good but maple is too strong, slightly too much bitterness. May be better with age?

2016 3 yo 4.4 excellent super sweet and flavorful

2017 almost 2 yo 4.5 excellent, super sweet, tasty and smooth

9 mo old 2018 4.4 excellent sweet and tasty

2017 1.5 y.o. 4.3 very sweet good - no floaties

2017 1 y.o. 4.4 excellent - super sweet

2016 2 y.o. 4.3 very good, but maybe not as good as fresher versions? huge amount of thick floaties making the last several oz undrinkable - drink fresher?

8 month 2017 4.5 excellent super sweet

4.2 2017 good sweet

1 y.o. 4.0

2016 2 y.o. 4.3 very good - not sure it's better than the 2017 I had recently

2017 1 y.o. 4.35 very good

2017 1 yo 4.2

2017 10 months old 4.35 excellent

Fresh 2017 4.35 Really good - but not as good as the 1 y.o. 2016 from the prior week

4.2 good but not great/special

15 mo. 4.1 seemed very spicy still

10 mo 4.25 really tasty and flavorful now, spice died down and more chocolatey

7 mo. 4.2

15 mo. 4.25 very tasty - not too spicy

10 mo. 4.1 still really spicy

4.1 very good, still spicy and not as chocolatey as the year old

9 mo old 4.2 very good - smooth

4.2 good spicy

fresh 2018 4.35 very good, spicy cinnamon

2016 2 y.o. 4.3 very good - not sure it's better than the 2017 I had recently

2017 1 y.o. 4.35 very good

2017 1 yo 4.2

2017 10 months old 4.35 excellent

Fresh 2017 4.35 Really good - but not as good as the 1 y.o. 2016 from the prior week

1 yo 4.2 very good smooth tasty but no rich sweet burnt sugar

2016 3 yo 4.35 really good, tasty and flavorful but maybe could be even less bitter/hoppy although only slightly so

2015 3 y.o. 4.3 Excellent super smooth, no bitterness. Tasty roasted malt flavors.

2017-10-22 1 y.o. 2016 but a newly purchased bottle on a rerelease from Surly. 4.25 very good but a little too bitter yet. Maybe not as "aged" as the one I had in the basement for a year? 2017-09-13 1 y.o. 2016 4.45 Excellent - maybe the best non BA IS I've had, super sweet burnt sugar roasted flavors