4.0 a little soury - rum barrel aged

6 yo 4.3 very good.

2017 4 yo 4.35 excellent

4.3 not as sweet

2016 4 yo 4.4 excellent

2017 3 yo 4.3 very good - a little less sweet toffee/caramel than I remember and a little (good) smokey-ish? flavor.

2017 2 yo 4.25 very good, but not as good as I thought it would be - maybe too cold

2017 1.75 yo 4.4 excellent

2017 18 mo. 4.35 very good, better as it warms more

2017 18 mo. 4.3 very good sweet and flavorful

2017 1 yo 4.3 very good, super smooth and sweet

2017 6 mo. old very good 4.35 even some burnt sugar as it really warmed. Drink warmer.

2017 fresh 4.25 not as sweet and smooth as the 2016 1 y.o. was. Lack of smoothness not bitterness, but acetone (?) alcohol flavor

2016 1 y.o. 4.75 Excellent smooth sweet perfection of an EBW 2016

4.75 excellent strong barrel aroma but smooth taste, nicely sweet with perfect barrel accent

3.0 tasty but horrible (yeast) chunks

2016 2 y.o. 4.3 very good - not sure it's better than the 2017 I had recently

2017 1 y.o. 4.35 very good

2017 1 yo 4.2

2017 10 months old 4.35 excellent

Fresh 2017 4.35 Really good - but not as good as the 1 y.o. 2016 from the prior week

1 y.o. 4.25 very good, smooth toasty roasted sweet nut influenced flavor

4.1 Pecan/roasted nut flavor was nice, slight roasted sugar flavor. Could be sweeter.

1 yo 4.2

9+ mo. 4.2 very good, smooth and tasty, but had a t a Brewer game

4.0 Good but maple is too strong, slightly too much bitterness. May be better with age?

2016 3 yo 4.4 excellent super sweet and flavorful

2017 almost 2 yo 4.5 excellent, super sweet, tasty and smooth

9 mo old 2018 4.4 excellent sweet and tasty

2017 1.5 y.o. 4.3 very sweet good - no floaties

2017 1 y.o. 4.4 excellent - super sweet

2016 2 y.o. 4.3 very good, but maybe not as good as fresher versions? huge amount of thick floaties making the last several oz undrinkable - drink fresher?

8 month 2017 4.5 excellent super sweet

4.2 2017 good sweet

1 y.o. 4.0

2016 2 y.o. 4.3 very good - not sure it's better than the 2017 I had recently

2017 1 y.o. 4.35 very good

2017 1 yo 4.2

2017 10 months old 4.35 excellent

Fresh 2017 4.35 Really good - but not as good as the 1 y.o. 2016 from the prior week

4.2 good but not great/special

15 mo. 4.1 seemed very spicy still

10 mo 4.25 really tasty and flavorful now, spice died down and more chocolatey

7 mo. 4.2

15 mo. 4.25 very tasty - not too spicy

10 mo. 4.1 still really spicy

4.1 very good, still spicy and not as chocolatey as the year old

9 mo old 4.2 very good - smooth

4.2 good spicy

fresh 2018 4.35 very good, spicy cinnamon

2016 2 y.o. 4.3 very good - not sure it's better than the 2017 I had recently

2017 1 y.o. 4.35 very good

2017 1 yo 4.2

2017 10 months old 4.35 excellent

Fresh 2017 4.35 Really good - but not as good as the 1 y.o. 2016 from the prior week

1 yo 4.2 very good smooth tasty but no rich sweet burnt sugar

2016 3 yo 4.35 really good, tasty and flavorful but maybe could be even less bitter/hoppy although only slightly so

2015 3 y.o. 4.3 Excellent super smooth, no bitterness. Tasty roasted malt flavors.

2017-10-22 1 y.o. 2016 but a newly purchased bottle on a rerelease from Surly. 4.25 very good but a little too bitter yet. Maybe not as "aged" as the one I had in the basement for a year? 2017-09-13 1 y.o. 2016 4.45 Excellent - maybe the best non BA IS I've had, super sweet burnt sugar roasted flavors

6 mo 4.2 good, smooth

4.15 good not great

4.1

4.1

1 yo 4.2 smooth tasty coffee flavor

about 6 mo. 4.2 very good, great coffee and smooth

4.2 great coffee and smooth

4.1

fresh 4.15 great coffee, smooth but the coffee dominates with not too much else in terms of flavor. Thinner like an IP.

Fresh 4.1 great coffee taste, but not much else. great value at 12.99/ 4 pack