1 yo appx 4.25 very good just a notch below the top dogs

3 yo 4.0 smooth pretty tasty but not very sweet

3 y. o. 4.15

Liked it a lot at 1 year. Very flavorful. 4.25?

4.35

4.4 still very good

4.4 super tasty

4.35 really good.

4.4

4.2 but a little sick with a cold???

4.5

4.5

4.5 excellent

4.5+ warm to start - excellent

4 mo old (guestimate) 4.5 excellent - smooth and tasty with a lot of burnt sugar sweetness

4.5 Excellent burnt sugar and very flavorful

4.4 excellent - really flavorful with burnt sugar and some coconut

4.5

Fresh 4.5 brunt sugar/roasted marshmallow sweetness, light on coconut. A lot like UJS.

Drain pour - tasted infected

at least 6 mo. <4 not much flavor

4.1 1+ yo smooth, still some rye spice not super sweet

2018 10 mo. 4.2 very good, smooth but not a ton of flavor/sweetness

4.1 very good smooth and fairly tasty

4.2 very smooth but not super sweet

4.25

fresh 4.25 Very good barrel flavor

2 yo 4.2 smooth and tasty

Almost 1 y.o. 4.1

6 mo. 4.1 good but not great - not much unique in terms of flavor

fresh 2017 4.0+ tasty but slightly bitter

1 y.o. 2016 4.2 very smooth, no bitterness, but not tons of flavors

2/18 so 2 yo 4.2 a little off on taste

4.3

2018 2 yo 4.2 great taste, but a little bitterness that I don't remember with this

8 mo old 4.4 excellent burnt sugar sweetness

2 y.o. 2016 4.3 smooth very tasty

fresh 4.2 smooth and tasty

2018 few months old 4.35

2016 3.5 yo 4.25 sweet and tasty, but a lot of sediment

6 yo 4.25 less sweet than fresher, more balanced, smooth and still flavorful

4.0 2001 super sweet - but too many floaties

4.18/5 rDev -1.6% look: 4.25 | smell: 4.25 | taste: 4.25 | feel: 4 | overall: 4 2012 vintage A - very nice orange color with nice carbonation S - subtle sweet T - light sweetness with fruity flavor - maybe apricot? M - nice, a bit light O - very good, definitely not a s sweet as the as fresher cask aged versions I've had

4.4

4 mo. old 4.4 super sweet burnt sugar

1 yo 4.5 excellent burnt sugar and chocolatey

4.2 Tasty but coconut wasn't real great

4.2 fresh. Very good, sweet flavorful milk stout

2018 4.5 yo 4.3 tasted a little off (oxidized?) at first but then better as I went

2018 3.5 yo 4.25 lacking a bit of expected flavor

almost 2.5 yrs. 4.35 sweet and very tasty (much more so than the 1.5 y.o. 2018 version)

1 yo 4.25 very good

9 mo 4.325 very good

7 mo. 4.35 excellent, great strong barrel

4.35

2018 6 mo. 4.3 excellent

4.35 Excellent

fresh 4.25 really good, sweet and smooth

fresh 4.3 really good - smooth, slightly sweet spot on BA EBW

2 yr 4 mo. 4.3 very good, smooth and tasty. longer could be better.

2 yo 4.35 Excellent now - very tasty and smooth, bitterness almost completely gone.

15 mo. 4.35 tasty and fairly smooth

1 yo 2017 4.2 very good, could be less bitter and sweeter, may be better (less bitter) with time

1 yo 4.15 good but not real sweet and slightly bitter - could be better aged longer, but probably not great as it's not that sweet