3 yo 4.25 a little off, not as sweet

2.5 yo 4.25 not as good (sweet, flavorful, smooth with no bitterness) as I remember

4.3 Sweet caramel and toffee and very smooth.

2018 2 yo 4.25 tasty but a little bitter???

4.25 smooth and tasty, not real sweet

9 mo. 4.25 tasty but a could be smoother

8 mo. 4.3 really good, smoothed out, and just right sweet

Fresh 4.2 very good, smooth but a little too (maple???) sweet

2017 3 yo 4.2 good but not great - smooth but not that flavorful and tasty

2017 2 yo 4.2 very good but not great

4.3 very good

4.2 Not that sweet or flavorful

4.56 on BA not sure how old - maybe 1 year?

2.5 yo 4.35 had up north - really good, sweet, flavorful and smooth

2.5 yo 4.35 Excellent, super smooth and tasty

2017 1.5 yo 4.35 excellent

6 mo. 4.2 good, but not as good/sweet as the 2 y.o. I had previously

4.3 very smooth and fairly sweet

5 yo 4.1 not that great, kind of lacking in flavor profile, but smooth

2014 4-5 yo very good, no particles, tasty but not quite port like

3 y.o. 4.35 Super smooth, more toffee/chocolate flavors

4.4 2 years old. Blind mini vert, preferred the 2 year old over one year.

4.75 Side by side with fresh. Good fresh but very good with 1 year of aging. Bite down, smoother and malt flavorful.

2.5 yr 4.4 smooth and best flavors as it warms

2018 2 yo 4.2 not as sweet as I remember

2015 5 yo 4.0 dropping off - not as sweet, somewhat cardboardy/aged ABW flavors. Maybe not aged well before I bought from a guy? The 4 yo was excellent - maybe that was the sweet spot?

2015 4 yo 4.25 Good but not as great/sweet as others. This was bought already maybe 3 years old, so maybe it wasn't stored properly?

2104 (Oct) so almost 5 years 4.5 excellent had up north on vacation, sweet and smooth.

2018 fresh 4.15 not as sweet as aged

4 y.o. 2014 4.5+ Excellent super smooth, sweet and flavorful

2015 2.5 y.o. 4.4 Excellent - sweet, sticky and smooth.

4 yo 4.7 Excellent. Had up north with Matt. Soo sweet and smooth. Last one :-(

4.5 1 y.o.

2015 4 yo 4.6 Excellent. Had up north with Matt, awesome sweet BQ stone fruit flavors and super smooth.

3 yo only 4.2 may be a recent purchase from Discount, so maybe on the shelf for a while?

3 y.o by year, 4.5 excellent, super sweet and sticky

5 y.o. 2013 4.1 not as good as fresher versions I've had. Was (on shelf) at Sonoma Cellars for 2.5 years, so maybe light or heat was the issue

3 yr. maybe - 2015 in Mar 2018 4.5 excellent, sweet dark fruit - perfect Belgian DSA

4.25 very sweet - not at all hot, but packs a punch!

4.5 Excellent. Probably about 2 years old. Maybe not quite as good (strong stone fruit sweetness, sticky moutfeel) as the one that was 9 month more aged that I had previously.

2013 vintage so 2-3 years old 4.83 look: 4 | smell: 4.75 | taste: 5 | feel: 4.5 | overall: 5A - Very dark brown/black, head dissipates quickly. S - Sweet, dark fruit and chocolate. T - Absolutely delicious. Very sweet, one of the sweetest beers I've had, but complex. Lots of sweet dark fruit, with the chocolate and coffee flavor of a very good stout. M - Thick and smooth, very nice. O - Excellent. BSDA are my favorite, and this probably jumped into my top five beers. If you like big sweet beers, I'd highly recommend it.

6 yo 4.3 very good.

2017 4 yo 4.35 excellent

4.3 not as sweet

2016 4 yo 4.4 excellent

2017 3 yo 4.3 very good - a little less sweet toffee/caramel than I remember and a little (good) smokey-ish? flavor.

2017 2 yo 4.25 very good, but not as good as I thought it would be - maybe too cold

2017 1.75 yo 4.4 excellent

2017 18 mo. 4.35 very good, better as it warms more

2017 18 mo. 4.3 very good sweet and flavorful

2017 1 yo 4.3 very good, super smooth and sweet

2017 6 mo. old very good 4.35 even some burnt sugar as it really warmed. Drink warmer.

2017 fresh 4.25 not as sweet and smooth as the 2016 1 y.o. was. Lack of smoothness not bitterness, but acetone (?) alcohol flavor

2016 1 y.o. 4.75 Excellent smooth sweet perfection of an EBW 2016

4.75 excellent strong barrel aroma but smooth taste, nicely sweet with perfect barrel accent

4.25 very good

4.2

4.25

4.25

Very good

4.3 very smooth and flavorful with great coconut

4.25 very good

4.2

4.25

4.25

Very good

4.3 very smooth and flavorful with great coconut

4.0

4.0 not much flavor

4.25 very good

4.2

4.25

4.25

Very good

4.3 very smooth and flavorful with great coconut

4.25 very good

4.2

4.25

4.25

Very good

4.3 very smooth and flavorful with great coconut

5 yo 4.3 starting to go down hill - was a bought recently from a store

4.5 yo 4.5 May have aged less than optimally in the store until recently purchased

3 y.o. 4.9 just superb!

4.9 Excellent I'm not sure what could be better - sweet but complex, smooth, balanced and sticky.

Very good 4.5

4.8/5 rDev +11.1% look: 4.25 | smell: 4.75 | taste: 5 | feel: 4.5 | overall: 4.75 9/14 bottling so aged 2 years A - red/brown/orange color with a quickly dissipating head S - wonderful complex sweetness with the barrel coming through nicely T - about as good as it gets - sweet smooth and balanced M - nice and sticky O - one of the best beers I've ever had - I was saving it for a special occasion and the Badgers beating LSU in the season opener was the perfect occasion!

4.35

4.4 still very good

4.4 super tasty

4.35 really good.

4.4

4.2 but a little sick with a cold???

4.5

4.5

4.5 excellent

4.5+ warm to start - excellent

4 mo old (guestimate) 4.5 excellent - smooth and tasty with a lot of burnt sugar sweetness

4.5 Excellent burnt sugar and very flavorful

4.4 excellent - really flavorful with burnt sugar and some coconut

4.5

Fresh 4.5 brunt sugar/roasted marshmallow sweetness, light on coconut. A lot like UJS.