9 mo. 4.2 coffee still a bit too dominant

4.0 fresh good, but too much coffee

2019 4.25 solid

2017 4 yo 4.25 a bit sorry at first, better more standard BA IS flavors as it warmed

2017 3 yo 4.25 smooth, pretty tasty

2017 2 yo 4.25 smooth for ABV tasty

2019 3yo 4.4 super sweet and tasty but not too sweet

2019 2 yo 4.35 great flavor and not too much maple flavor

2018 3 yo 4.35 very smooth, sweet and tasty good maple flavors

2 yo 4.35 excellent. Very sweet and tasty

9 mo. 4.2 very good - maple syrup flavor still pretty strong but not in a bad way

fresh 4.0 incredibly smooth for the ABUs, but maple syrup sweet taste wasn't appealing

??? 4.1 good? don't remember

7 mo old 4.3 still really great

6 mo. + old 4.3

4.25

4.3 very tasty

4.3 very tasty and smooth

4.25 very good

4.2

4.25

4.25

Very good

4.3 very smooth and flavorful with great coconut

4.2 very thick and tasty

4.4 very good

4.3 very tasty, smooth and super thick

4.4 1 yo Excellent after a year - the barrel mellow out and was not sharpe or dominating as I remembered

Fresh 4.1 light, slight fruit from the barrel but not that flavorful

4.25 real good.

4.2 very good

2018 1 yo 4.3 very sweet and tasty

2017 2 yo 4.4 excellent very tasty and smooth

2018 so 6-9 mo old 4.35 very good, sweet sticky

6 mo + 4.2 not as sweet but very smooth and balanced - very good

6 mo old 2018 4.1 good not great - not as sweet (or sticky) as in past

2018 fresh 4.2 - not as sticky (or sweet?) and good as the older 2017's. May be the difference in vintage, or maybe it really changes and improves with time.

4.25 very good

4.2

4.25

4.25

Very good

4.3 very smooth and flavorful with great coconut

3 yo 4.25 a little off, not as sweet

2.5 yo 4.25 not as good (sweet, flavorful, smooth with no bitterness) as I remember

4.3 Sweet caramel and toffee and very smooth.

2018 2 yo 4.25 tasty but a little bitter???

4.25 smooth and tasty, not real sweet

9 mo. 4.25 tasty but a could be smoother

8 mo. 4.3 really good, smoothed out, and just right sweet

Fresh 4.2 very good, smooth but a little too (maple???) sweet

4.2 cognac barrel tasty barrel but not a lot more than that

2016 3 yo 4.35 really good, tasty and flavorful but maybe could be even less bitter/hoppy although only slightly so

2015 3 y.o. 4.3 Excellent super smooth, no bitterness. Tasty roasted malt flavors.

2017-10-22 1 y.o. 2016 but a newly purchased bottle on a rerelease from Surly. 4.25 very good but a little too bitter yet. Maybe not as "aged" as the one I had in the basement for a year? 2017-09-13 1 y.o. 2016 4.45 Excellent - maybe the best non BA IS I've had, super sweet burnt sugar roasted flavors

4.2 very thick and tasty

4.4 very good

4.3 very tasty, smooth and super thick