2015 3 y.o. 4.5 Excellent - super sweet and smooth.

2 year 4 months old. 4.4 very good -sweet and smooth

4.1 losing sweetness

4.25 losing sweetness?

4.5 Excellent at 20 months

excellent at 1.5 years

4.5ish super sweet and delicious at one year very much like a sherry morphed old ale

4.47 Super sweet and tasty - similar to samiclaus, JW Lees, Fullers.

4.0 Very good - nice strong barrel that goes well with the Brown Ale, but not too much of other flavors (like BA RISs)

Better fresh - smooth but thinner and lighter in flavor.

1 year + losing flavor 3.5

didn't pay enough attention to notice if it improved

4.25 excellent

2.5 y.o. very good 4.2

Very good as always

Excellent but Preferred the 2012 to the 2014 in blind tasting (even sweeter)

3.75 the cinnamon or something in the added flavors didn't work well

22 months 3.8 still too bitter like an ABW

1.5 years still a bit bitter but better with time maybe 3.75

4 tasty, but still too much bitterness that American Barleywine displays - still thinking two or three years may be the sweet spot if there is one.

4.1 good - bitterness subsided, sweeter BW flavors

4.25+ vanilla bourbon barrel with a little heat, subtle coffee and sweet burnt sugar

good - i think better fresh

4.25 very good, smooth marshmallow sweet.

10 months. 4.375 - coffee pretty much gone. still sweet and tasty, w/ burnt sugar, toasty roasted marshmallow. Drink fresher. Definitely need to have this warmer - 45-55 is too low at the low end. 55 is best.

2 months 4.55/5 rDev 0% look: 4.25 | smell: 4.75 | taste: 4.5 | feel: 4.5 | overall: 4.5 A - Dark brown smallish tan head S - Super - sweet burnt sugar smell T - Awesome complex sweetness, burnt sugar, vanilla, coffee M - nice and sticky O - Excellent, so smooth sweet and tasty

2 y.o. 2016 a little sharpe but tasty, not hot, and kicking

1 y.o. 4.2 getting even better, a bit hot but very flavorful burnt sugar taste.

4 very good - interesting, fun to drink, not too hot fresh as expected. had to sip slowly, probably would be better with some time.

3.9 good but not worth chasing

< 4 ok 7 months old still a little harsh

4.1 now 4 months old. Getting better - smoother

4 very good. Not as good as CW? A little too hot?

1+ y.o. 4.3 extremely smooth, sweet, sticky, but a little of the carbonation/chest pressure issue

4 very nice sweet taste, although maybe too sugary? Problem with the chest pain/gas issue.

4.2 very good at 7 mo. but would go too much longer

6 mo. really good 4.25 maybe could be even better with time/less bitterness and coffee still strong enough

4.35 slight bitterness on first few sips, then smooth and flavorful. The coffee is still very strong.

4.25 Very good again.

4.55/5 rDev +4.4% look: 4.25 | smell: 4.75 | taste: 4.5 | feel: 4.5 | overall: 4.5 L - Black/brown with strong tan head S - Strong coffee, strong barrel vanilla sweetness T - Coffee and bourbon barrel are strong, vanilla sweetness, slight bitter finish M - Nice stickiness O - Very good, highly recommended for the price relative to other BBA coffee stouts Possibly could smooth out and improve with some age

4+ very good - richer than fresh

liking it even a bit better at 14 mo. maybe close to 4

3.75 at 11 months, good but not that sweet

3.95 good - typical BSDA flavors, but a bit light. maybe stronger/sweeter with age?

Better fresh - smooth but thinner and lighter in flavor.

1 year + losing flavor 3.5

didn't pay enough attention to notice if it improved

2015 5+ yr 4.0 not great - some flavor (Licorice?) that I don't like

3.5 1 year, a bit of a hot mess. Strange booziy flavors. Wait at least 3 years maybe 5?