| Private Jet | Magnify Brewing | | |
| Private Reserve Imperial Stout | Crooked Stave Artisan Beer Project | American Imperial Stout | 14.5% |
| Private Rye | Jack's Abby | Bière de Garde | 6.2% |
| Private Stock Ale | AleSmith Brewing Company | Old Ale | 11.0% |
| Private Stock Imperial Bohemian Pilsner | The Narragansett Brewing Company | Imperial Pilsner | 8.6% |
| Private Stock Imperial Russian Stout | The Narragansett Brewing Company | Russian Imperial Stout | 8.5% |
| Privyet | Destihl | Russian Imperial Stout | 12.4% |
| Prize Old Ale | George Gale & Company | Old Ale | 9.0% |
| Pro-Am Foreign Extra Stout | Joseph James Brewing | | 7.0% |
| Pro-Am Pilsner | Jack's Abby | | |
| Pro-Tel Memorial Malt Liquor | Great Dane Pub and Brewing | American Lager | |
| Proast | Twin Oast Brewing | | 6.0% |
| Probability Engine | Modern Times | American Imperial Stout | 11.0% |
| Problem No Problem | Jolly Pumpkin Artisan Ales | Saison | 7.6% |
| Problem, No Problem | Jolly Pumpkin Artisan Ales / Monkish Brewing | | |