| I Rate Saison | Brasserie de la Senne | Saison | 5.5% |
| I Remember My First Check-In | Brouwerij het Uiltje | | 6.0% |
| I See A Darkness (Bottle Conditioned w/ Emptiness Yeast) | Tired Hands | | 8.5% |
| I See A Rainbow Rising | G.L.O.W. - Gangsta Ladies of Wort | German Pilsner | 3.4% |
| I See a Tartness | Sante Adairius Rustic Ales | American Porter | 8.4% |
| I See The Vision (Apricot & Boysenberry) | Burlington Beer Company | American IPA | 7.0% |
| I Shall Be Your Light | Anchorage Brewing Co | American IPA | 6.5% |
| I Stepped in Mud | Pips Meadery | | 14.0% |
| I Strata My NEIPA | Sibeeria | New England IPA | 6.0% |
| I Think I Can | Perennial Artisan Ales | Wild Ale | 6.1% |
| I Think I Just Scored! | Local Craft Beer | Imperial IPA | 10.0% |
| I Think I Saw | The Eighth State Brewing Company | American Imperial Stout | |
| I Think She Hung The Moon | Naughty Brewing Co. | | 8.6% |
| I Think We Should Go Home | Burial Beer Co. | Imperial IPA | 8.2% |
| I Think We're Gonna Be Alright | Burial Beer Co. | New England IPA | 8.5% |