| Double Paperweight | Urban Artifact | Fruit and Field Beer | 10.0% |
| Double Paw | The Livery | Imperial IPA | 8.5% |
| Double Peach La Tache | The Ale Apothecary | Wild Ale | 7.8% |
| Double Peach Marshmallow Kush | Foreign Local | Imperial IPA | 8.0% |
| Double Pear Vanilla - Vanilla Bourbon Barrels | Brewlihan Mead Company | | |
| Double Perigosa | Bodebrown | Imperial IPA | 15.1% |
| Double Perky Porter | Stillmank Beer Company | Imperial Porter | 10.1% |
| Double Perle | Weird Beard Brew Company | Sweet / Milk Stout | 8.6% |
| Double Pie Assassin | Anchorage Brewing Co | Imperial IPA | 8.4% |
| Double Pig’s Ear Double Down Brown Ale | Woodstock Inn Brewery | American Brown Ale | 8.4% |
| Double Pillow | Common Roots Brewing Company | New England IPA | 8.0% |
| Double Pilsner | Odell Brewing | American Lager | 8.1% |
| Double Piña Colada Chantilly | Phase Three Brewing Company | Imperial IPA | 9.0% |
| Double Pink Guava and Red Currant | Hudson Valley Brewery | | |
| DOUBLE PLATINUM | Starr Hill | Imperial IPA | 8.6% |