| Mr. Owl | Seventh Son Brewing Co | American Brown Ale | 8.5% |
| Mr. Peach | Highway Manor | | 5.2% |
| Mr. Pineapple | San Tan Brewing Company | | 5.0% |
| Mr. Pink | To Øl | Berliner Weisse | 4.5% |
| Mr. Plum | Highway Manor | | |
| Mr. President | BrewDog Ltd | American IPA | 9.2% |
| Mr. Saison | Trinity Brewing Company | Saison | 5.6% |
| Mr. Samurai Karate Guy | Oliphant | | 5.8% |
| Mr. Sanders | Bruery Terreux | Saison | 9.4% |
| Mr. Sandman | River North Brewery | American Imperial Stout | 12.9% |
| Mr. Sandman - Mayan Chocolate | River North Brewery | American Imperial Stout | 12.1% |
| Mr. Sandman - Milk Chocolate | River North Brewery | Sweet / Milk Stout | 11.0% |
| Mr. Sandman - Vanilla Bourbon Barrel Aged | River North Brewery | American Imperial Stout | 12.9% |
| Mr. Sandman - Vanilla Cinnamon Rum Barrel-Aged | River North Brewery | American Imperial Stout | 12.8% |
| Mr. Sandman Chai Spice | River North Brewery | American Imperial Stout | 12.1% |